Three-model hybrid royalty protocol (Network-Aligned, Custom, Optional) with sliding scale fees, node preference filtering, cohort bonuses, token reward matching, and full governance control.
Creator royalties are the single largest unsolved problem in decentralized marketplaces. Every major platform that has attempted to enforce them has either been undercut by competitors or abandoned enforcement entirely. Every platform that made them optional triggered a race to the bottom that destroyed creator revenue.
This document describes a third path: a three-model hybrid system where honoring royalties is the economically rational choice for every participant -- creators, node operators, and buyers -- without requiring enforcement mechanisms that can be circumvented.
The Enforcement Trap
Every major NFT marketplace has failed at royalty enforcement. The pattern is consistent:
Why On-Chain Enforcement Cannot Work (Generally)
Why Optional Models Fail
Our marketplace charges a 2.0% total fee (1.0% foundation + 1.0% reward pool). Competitors (OpenSea, Magic Eden) charge 2.5%. This 0.5% gap is dead value -- it does not benefit creators, buyers, or the network.
Give the 0.5% gap to creators as the baseline royalty. This costs the network nothing while making it the only marketplace where creators earn revenue by default.
This creates a marketplace where:
This is not enforcement. This is incentive alignment.
| Model | Rate Range | Enforcement | Who Pays | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Network-Aligned | 0.5%--1.0% | Enforced via node cohort | Seller (always) | Default for most collections |
| Custom | 0%--5.0% | Enforced or clamped to node max | Buyer or seller | Premium drops, high-demand |
| Optional | Any | Buyer toggle at checkout | Buyer (voluntary) | Community-driven, experimental |
The flagship model. Base rate is 0.5% (50 BPS) -- the gap between our 2.0% fee and the industry standard 2.5%.
Volume-Based Sliding Scale: As a collection's 30-day volume grows, foundation and the reward pool each contribute additional basis points from their 1.0% shares:
| Collection Volume (30d USD) | Foundation Contrib | Node Contrib | Creator Royalty | Foundation Fee | Node Fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $0 -- $9,999 | 0 BPS | 0 BPS | 0.50% | 1.00% | 1.00% |
| $10,000+ | 5 BPS | 5 BPS | 0.60% | 0.95% | 0.95% |
| $100,000+ | 12 BPS | 13 BPS | 0.75% | 0.88% | 0.87% |
| $1,000,000+ | 25 BPS | 25 BPS | 1.00% | 0.75% | 0.75% |
At maximum contribution: creators receive 1.0%, foundation 0.75%, nodes 0.75%. Total fee: 2.5% -- matching competitors, but with 1.0% going to the creator instead of the marketplace.
This is the only marketplace where reducing the buyer's cost simultaneously increases the creator's revenue.
For premium collections, creators set a custom rate up to 5.0% (500 BPS). The maximum is governance-capped.
Payer Mode:
Graduated Decay: Custom royalties support time-based decay. A collection might launch at 4.0% with 0.1% decay per epoch and a 1.0% floor. Early buyers pay a premium during peak demand; later buyers pay a sustainable long-term rate.
Total Cap: Collections can set a maximum cumulative royalty payout. Once reached, rate drops to zero. Useful for limited-edition collections.
Node Compatibility: Nodes declare their maximum supported rate. If a collection asks for 4% but a node supports up to 2%, the royalty is clamped to 2% on that node. Nodes compete on royalty support, not elimination.
Creators set royalties as purely optional. Buyer sees a toggle at checkout with the creator's suggested rate. Royalty outputs are marked as OPTIONAL_ROYALTY in the transaction.
Node operators are active economic participants with three incentives to support royalties:
1. Cohort Selection Bonus: Nodes accepting higher royalty rates score higher in gateway cohort selection. A node supporting 3%+ royalties receives a +1.5 scoring bonus (out of typical 10--18 total score). More traffic, more fees, more volume.
2. Leaderboard & Reputation: Royalty facilitation contributes to relay score. Nodes facilitating significant volume earn the "Royalty Steward" title in the public explorer.
3. Token Reward Matching: When token rewards are active, royalty-paying transactions receive a 1.5x token reward multiplier. Buyers earn 50% more token rewards on royalty-supporting transactions.
Node operators configure preferences via environment variables: ROYALTY_MAX_BPS=500 and ROYALTY_OPTIONAL=true.
| Collection Model | Node Max BPS | Node Optional | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Network-Aligned | >= effective rate | any | Enforced at sliding rate |
| Network-Aligned | < effective rate | false | Node excluded from cohort |
| Network-Aligned | < effective rate | true | Optional at effective rate |
| Custom (e.g. 4%) | >= 4% | false | Enforced at 4% |
| Custom (e.g. 4%) | < 4%, > 0 | false | Clamped to node max |
| Custom (e.g. 4%) | any | true | Buyer-optional at 4% |
| Optional | any | any | Always buyer-optional |
The system never blocks a transaction. If no nodes can meet the royalty requirement, it falls back to legacy behavior. Creator revenue degrades gracefully rather than failing absolutely.
| Platform | Marketplace Fee | Creator Royalty | Total Buyer Cost | Creator Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenSea OS2 | 0.5% | Optional (0%) | 0.5% | $0 (unless ERC-721C) |
| Blur | 0% | Optional (0%) | 0% | $0 |
| Magic Eden | 2.0% | Optional / OCP | 2.0% + royalty | Variable |
| Ours (Network-Aligned) | 2.0% | 0.5--1.0% (included) | 2.0% | 0.5--1.0% |
| Ours (Custom, seller-pays) | 2.0% | Up to 5.0% (deducted) | 2.0% | Up to 5.0% |
Governed by the creatorRoyaltyPolicy configuration key. Tier: ECONOMIC (3x stake multiplier, 3x voting power, +1 voter offset, 48-hour lock).
| Parameter | Default | Range | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
enabled | false | -- | Master switch (requires governance vote) |
networkAlignedBaseBps | 50 | 0--100 | Base royalty for Network-Aligned |
networkAlignedMaxFoundationContribBps | 25 | 0--50 | Max foundation contribution |
networkAlignedMaxNodeContribBps | 25 | 0--50 | Max node contribution |
customRoyaltyMaxBps | 500 | 0--500 | Max rate for Custom model |
customRoyaltyDefaultPayerMode | SELLER_PAYS | SELLER/BUYER | Default payer mode |
cohortRoyaltyBonusEnabled | true | -- | Node cohort scoring bonus |
cohortRoyaltyBonusMaxScore | 150 | 0--200 | Max bonus (hundredths) |
tokenRewardRoyaltyMatchingEnabled | false | -- | Token reward multiplier |
tokenRewardRoyaltyMatchMultiplier | 1.5 | 1.0--3.0 | Reward multiplier |
This flywheel does not depend on enforcement, airdrops, or temporary incentives. It is self-sustaining because every participant's rational economic interest aligns with honoring creator royalties.